Wyoming Whiskey Private Stock Barrel #1537 Review Header

Wyoming Whiskey Private Stock Barrel #1537 Review

In Bourbon Whiskey Reviews by Bob BennettLeave a Comment

Each season, Wyoming Whiskey distiller Sam Mead hand-selects a few special and unique 5-year aged barrels of our Small Batch Bourbon to be part of our Private Stock program. Every barrel is unique. Come raid our private stock.Wyoming Whiskey
Click to explore our complete library of reviews to help you choose your next perfect bottle.

Wyoming Whiskey Private Stock Barrel #1537

  • DISTILLER: Wyoming Whiskey
  • MASH BILL: 68% Corn  |  20% Winter Wheat  |  12% Malted Barley
  • AGE: 6 Years and 15 days
  • YEAR: 2017
  • PROOF: 109.2 (54.6% ABV)
  • MSRP: $60.00
  • BUY ONLINE: South Lyndale Liquors

NOSE: Hay  |  Oranges  |  Cinnamon

TASTE: Honey  |  Oranges  |  Baking Spices  |  Caramel

FINISH: Medium length with more of the cinnamon & oranges that have been present throughout.

SHARE WITH: Experienced whiskey drinkers will appreciate this one, but it’s also something that’s accessible to those who enjoy whiskey but haven’t had significant experience yet.  This drinks much lower than its proof, so it’s not going to hit those over the head who aren’t accustomed to barrel-strength whiskeys.

WORTH THE PRICE: $60 for a private pick, barrel-strength wheated bourbon is a pretty solid deal.  I have no problem spending that here.

BOTTLE, BAR OR BUST: Barrel-strength options for a wheated bourbon are scarce.  Combine that with the unique profile of this one and you won’t go wrong picking up a bottle.  Being a private selection from a liquor store in Minneapolis, it’s also the only likely opportunity to grab one.

OVERALL: I’m fortunate I had a full bottle of this to review, so I could take a little extra time and enjoy multiple pours over the course of a few weeks.  The more time I spent with it, the more I enjoyed it as it has a unique nose and flavor profile that I don’t find often.  A drop of water took out some ethanol notes on the nose and brought forward the cinnamon that wasn’t noticeable previously.  The honey hits you as soon as the whiskey hits your tongue, with the caramel being more present after a drop of water. Being that it’s summer when I’m drinking this, the orange & honey together are a perfect accent to the season.  A medium-to-full-bodied mouthfeel helps accentuate the finish, lingering a little longer than one would expect for a 5-year old whiskey.  A great pour all the way through.

This bottle is a tribute to what the folks at Wyoming Whiskey are doing.  I’m always pleased when I find an independent distillery making their own whiskey.  For them to be able to offer a barrel-strength private barrel program as well, with these results, is impressive.  I look forward to seeing what the brand has in store next.

Learn more about Bob’s whiskey preferences and check out more of his reviews…

About the Author
Bob Bennett

Bob Bennett


The fifteen months Bob Bennett spent living in Lebanon, KY, as a child may have laid the groundwork for what would happen years later (something in the water…literally). Originally from Corning, NY, he grew up in a household where happy hour was celebrated every night. Surprisingly, Bennett didn’t start drinking until he was 23 years old. He quickly made up for lost time, gravitating to bourbon as his preferred libation immediately, and proudly filled the bar that was passed down from his father. In the years that followed, not only did he develop a deeper appreciation for bourbon, but began to cherish the opportunity to talk about the spirit he has grown to love. As the Artistic Director for Jazz St. Louis, Bennett has become the unofficial bourbon ambassador of jazz, spreading the gospel of good taste to musicians everywhere. It also helps endear him to the St. Louis community, which is needed, as bleeding Dodger Blue tends to rub those Cardinal fans the wrong way.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.